Man who threw away $500M Bitcoin hard drive sues city for right to search landfill

Shawn Knight

Posts: 15,541   +196
Staff member
Recap: Desperate times call for desperate measures and with more than half a billion dollars potentially at stake, times are certainly desperate for one British man. Back in 2013, computer engineer James Howells made a grave mistake by accidentally tossing a hard driving containing a key to unlock thousands Bitcoins. It was reportedly one of two 2.5-inch drives he intended to get rid of, but he disposed of the wrong one by mistake.

Howells eventually realized what he'd done, but it was too late. His bag of trash from that day is believed to be at the local landfill, and is likely buried under several feet of garbage. Attempts to gain access to the landfill to excavate the missing drive have come up short, and Howells is now suing the local city council for the opportunity.

As Wales Online highlights, Howells is suing the council for the value of the Bitcoins at their peak from earlier this year. Howells told the publication that the suit is more about persuading the council to let him try and find the hard drive at the landfill.

With so much money now on the line, Howells quit his job and is focused full time on the search and rescue operation. He has hired a team of experts that have invested in the mission in exchange for a cut of the proceeds if the coins are ever recovered. Howells has even offered to give the city 10 percent of the haul. All said, he'd be left with about 30 percent of his original stash or around $150 million.

Of course, the whole thing could be for not. Even if Howells was able to somehow find the drive, it's been sitting in a landfill for more than a decade. Still, his team of experts believe there is about an 80 percent chance that data from the drive would be recoverable.

In a statement to Whales Online, the council said they've told Howells multiple times that excavation is not possible under their environmental permit and that such a job would have a profoundly negative impact on the surrounding area.

Permalink to story:

 
*for naught. Might want to fix the article.

As for this guy, he's f-ed up, but he needs to let it go. Quitting your job and focusing solely on this for 11 years?
I know the money sounds like it's worth it, but the council have told him a hundred different ways why he isn't allowed to dig around in there, so it's a non - starter. Does he really think the councils aren't strapped for cash? If they were offered that kinda dough and it was something they could do they'd have bit his hand off years ago, when it would've been much easier to find, not another decade of rubbish piled on top.

 
With that kind of money at stake, you would think the person would of taken better measures to make sure nothing happened. It's not like losing your wallet or phone.
Back in 2013 it wasn't worth anywhere near as much?

Edit: Should have added, he mined them in 2009, when Bitcoin wasn't worth anything.
 
Last edited:
Oh well he has a purpose to live I suppose.
Those real life docos gold, opals etc think the people are actually addicted to the process. I mean some 65 year old could be working 14 hours a day if they thought they were on to something. 50% of other people glancing at clock to see it 5pm

my own opinion is I hear a Frozen song
 
He's still digging? LOL. I thought he would have hanged himself by now.
 
Last edited:
The only thing that uniquely distinguishes a hard drive in a garbage field is its magnets and the magnetic field they generate.
So you need to search with something like this (shop.sphengineering.com/en-en/products/magnimbus-magnetometer)
 
Finders keepers, losers weepers?

Yes, I do have some severe problems with empathy. Maybe I'm a sociopath, who knows?
 
Finders keepers, losers weepers?

Agreed. I don't have much empathy here. Then again, if I knew I threw out a hard drive potentially worth half a billion, and I had a good idea of where it was, I too might go stir crazy trying to get it back. Still, a decade is a long time. Time to let bygones be bygones.
 
"Whales Online"...really??...........
But wait....maybe there's a joke about a crypto-bro losing everything and 'blubbering' about it??

Whatever........absolutely F-all sympathy coming from me. Crypto tosspots were the cause of me not being able to get my hands on a decent graphics card back in the day.
 
So the hdd is 500M but his only offering 50M (10%) [assumption] to the council and his saying he be left with 150M - to clarify 150M+50M!=500M. Has he already spent 300M looking for it?

Like everyone's been saying f**k him. He doesn't understand how landfills work and you simply can not unearth the f**k out of it, and expect to maintain the strict environmental and containment requirements. Simply put, there is far too much risk.

Lets imagine for a moment we incinerate all waste and recycled ALL e-waste. His hdd would be long gone!
 
Did he actually need a hard drive? Isn't a bitcoin account described adequately simply by an account number and a password?

if that's the case he could have backed it up just with a piece of paper in his wallet.
 
He will have an unbelievable story to tell, how he almost had $500M.

What keeps landfill guys from finding the drive themselves?
 
He will have an unbelievable story to tell, how he almost had $500M.

What keeps landfill guys from finding the drive themselves?

They need the password then and would have reached out to him for sure.

This drive is probably crushed to dust by now. Zero hope. He should probably just give up.
 
A front loader probably already crushed the drive beyond use of any means. The guy done did F up, get over it.

Anyway, the dump is a private company, they can tell you pound sand all day long. They have reason to allow a chump and his "what if" dreams on the premises.
 
So the hdd is 500M but his only offering 50M (10%) [assumption] to the council and his saying he be left with 150M - to clarify 150M+50M!=500M. Has he already spent 300M looking for it?

Like everyone's been saying f**k him. He doesn't understand how landfills work and you simply can not unearth the f**k out of it, and expect to maintain the strict environmental and containment requirements. Simply put, there is far too much risk.

Lets imagine for a moment we incinerate all waste and recycled ALL e-waste. His hdd would be long gone!
Remember, he still has to pay taxes on all that crypto, 28% for his long term gains. And he has to pay for all the legal expenses over the last half decade + of looking for this thing. And he quit his job, so gotta cover that. And you have to pay transaction fees, there's hundreds of thousands gone.
Back in 2013 it wasn't worth anywhere near as much?
But the whole reason one would buy bitcoin in the first place was to let it appreciate and make a profit. Even if it wasnt "that much" back then, he'd likely have still had the mindset of making money, so he should have taken at least SOME measures to not throw out the drive.

Depending on when he bought, he paid anywhere from $1-200 per coin. At the current price, he would have bought 7390 coins. So bare minimum, he spent $739,000 on bitcoin for that hard drive. It's not like he spent $5 and forgot, he invested serious dosh.

I know I'd be guarding a hard drive with $739k of investment on it with 007 tier security.
 
Regardless of the drive being in a data recoverable state - how in the world does he expect to find it in a landfill. Landfills are massive and are layered over and over with more refuse.

A 'wide view' portable XRay machine? (that even exist?) To see through the depths of trash looking for a specific size/shape?
 
Regardless of the drive being in a data recoverable state - how in the world does he expect to find it in a landfill. Landfills are massive and are layered over and over with more refuse.

A 'wide view' portable XRay machine? (that even exist?) To see through the depths of trash looking for a specific size/shape?
Landfills typically keep records on what trash was deposited on what sector, typically by month. So if you wanted to dig, you'd be able to track down the layer and general location, depending on the records you might even know what pile came from which week.

After that, ground radar is a thing, same thing you'd use for finding fossils. I dont know if he'd be able to find a hard drive in all that, but hell for half a billion id give it a shot.
 
But the whole reason one would buy bitcoin in the first place was to let it appreciate and make a profit. Even if it wasnt "that much" back then, he'd likely have still had the mindset of making money, so he should have taken at least SOME measures to not throw out the drive.

Depending on when he bought, he paid anywhere from $1-200 per coin. At the current price, he would have bought 7390 coins. So bare minimum, he spent $739,000 on bitcoin for that hard drive. It's not like he spent $5 and forgot, he invested serious dosh.

I know I'd be guarding a hard drive with $739k of investment on it with 007 tier security.
He didn't buy any Bitcoin, he mined them in 2009, I remember getting my Nvidia 780 GPU and mining a bit of Bitcoin in 2013 to buy some pizza, as Domino's had started taking Bitcoin.

Back then (2009) when he mined said coin, it wasn't worth anything, probably upgraded his PC and was changing the HDD over, accidently threw it out as it was a perfectly working HDD, then realised that the coins were worth serious money.
 
Back